Methodology

The survey begins with four colour-vision screening plates and one unrecorded practice question. It then presents 29 measured figure questions covering the design comparisons shown below.

Degradation crossing — Redundant Encoding

Redundant Encoding tested at both levels, under both normal and greyscale rendering. The normal and greyscale cells in the same row share identical underlying data -- only the colour transform differs -- so any difference between them is the degradation, not a data change.

viewing condition: baseline viewing condition: treatment
level: baseline

Scattered categorical point cloud: 14 samples split 8/4/2 across three categories. Redundant Encoding = baseline (Colour-only identity encoding).

tokens
redundant_encoding = baseline
viewing
normal
prompt
Which of the three categories has the MOST samples?
options
Category 1, Category 2, Category 3, Skip
answer
Category 1
pool
degradation_crossing / scatter / normal / redundant_encoding=baseline
draw
degradation_crossing:scatter:normal:redundant_encoding=baseline · variant 3

Scattered categorical point cloud: 14 samples split 8/4/2 across three categories. Redundant Encoding = baseline (Colour-only identity encoding). Rendered in greyscale to test whether the encoding survives colour loss.

tokens
redundant_encoding = baseline
viewing
greyscale
prompt
Which of the three categories has the MOST samples?
options
Category 1, Category 2, Category 3, Skip
answer
Category 1
pool
degradation_crossing / scatter / greyscale / redundant_encoding=baseline
draw
degradation_crossing:scatter:grayscale:redundant_encoding=baseline · variant 3
level: treatment

Scattered categorical point cloud: 14 samples split 8/4/2 across three categories. Redundant Encoding = treatment (Colour plus a second independent channel).

tokens
redundant_encoding = treatment
viewing
normal
prompt
Which of the three categories has the MOST samples?
options
Category 1, Category 2, Category 3, Skip
answer
Category 1
pool
degradation_crossing / scatter / normal / redundant_encoding=treatment
draw
degradation_crossing:scatter:normal:redundant_encoding=treatment · variant 3

Scattered categorical point cloud: 14 samples split 8/4/2 across three categories. Redundant Encoding = treatment (Colour plus a second independent channel). Rendered in greyscale to test whether the encoding survives colour loss.

tokens
redundant_encoding = treatment
viewing
greyscale
prompt
Which of the three categories has the MOST samples?
options
Category 1, Category 2, Category 3, Skip
answer
Category 1
pool
degradation_crossing / scatter / greyscale / redundant_encoding=treatment
draw
degradation_crossing:scatter:grayscale:redundant_encoding=treatment · variant 3